News

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has approved a new Review of Judicial Practice for 2026

Legal Alerts
The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation has approved a new Review of Judicial Practice for 2026.

Our team has prepared a series of posts dedicated to this review.

Below, we provide our commentary on significant legal positions concerning cases involving consumers.

Clause 3: Consumer protection rights may be invoked by an individual who acquired a product through a chain of resales, provided that the original purchaser acquired the item exclusively for personal, family, household, or other non-commercial purposes—that is, for needs unrelated to the conduct of business activities.

This position stems from a case reviewed by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation involving the sale of a vehicle through a chain: Original Seller → First Buyer (a company) → Final Buyer (an individual).

The vehicle was not sold on the retail market, and the initial buyer was a legal entity, which does not qualify as a "consumer."

After acquiring the vehicle, the final buyer asserted claims against the original seller based on the Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights.

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation confirmed that the provisions of the Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights cannot be applied if no consumer relationship existed between the original seller and the first buyer—specifically, because the vehicle was not originally sold on the retail market and was not intended for the consumer market (i.e., for individual, non-commercial buyers).

The Supreme Court reaffirmed that the mere fact that an individual ultimately acquires a product does not automatically trigger the application of the Law on the Protection of Consumer Rights.

Clause 4: Compensation for damages—calculated as the price difference when a defective product is returned—is intended to restore a consumer’s violated rights. Such compensation must be balanced to protect the interests of both parties and must not result in the consumer’s unjust enrichment; this necessitates establishing the actual extent of the damages with a reasonable degree of certainty.

This position stems from a case reviewed by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation concerning the recovery of damages in the form of a price difference. The plaintiff had purchased a vehicle for 1.7 million rubles, but, due to defects, subsequently bought another one for 4.1 million rubles and sought to recover the price difference from the defendant as damages.

The plaintiff argued that the two vehicles were "analogous" within the meaning of Article 24 of the Law on Protection of Consumer Rights, as they shared similar consumer and technical characteristics. Lower courts accepted this argument and ruled in favor of the plaintiff.

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation disagreed, noting that establishing the amount of damages with a reasonable degree of certainty—when claiming the difference in price—depends on the specific characteristics of what is considered an "analogous" product.

When determining whether a product is "analogous," one must consider not only its technical specifications but also its "functional purpose, intended use, and quality characteristics." The term "quality characteristics" should be understood to include, among other factors, the product's manufacturer.

If an identical product is not available on the market, priority should be given to products from the same manufacturer. Furthermore, the Supreme Court emphasized the need to compare the price categories of the products, as well as their classifications according to international standards, where applicable.

This stance is intended to protect sellers from unscrupulous consumers who, having purchased a more expensive product, attempt to gain an advantage by shifting the resulting price difference onto the business owner.