We are continuing our series of posts dedicated to the new Review of Judicial Practice from the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation for 2026.
You can find the first post here.
In this post, we will discuss the Supreme Court’s positions regarding advertising legislation and procedural matters.
Clause 3: The installation of an advertising structure on a building’s roof, in the absence of evidence that the established public regulatory procedures for such installation were followed, constitutes grounds for the mandatory dismantling of the structure, regardless of its functional purpose.
This legal position emerged from a dispute reviewed by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which addressed the necessity of complying not only with advertising legislation but also with broader public regulatory requirements.
A municipal authority issued an order to a company to dismantle an advertising structure placed on its roof, citing the lack of a required installation permit.
The courts of first instance and the appellate court upheld the order as lawful. However, the district cassation court took a different view, arguing that the structure in question was an informational sign rather than an advertisement; therefore, its placement did not fall under the requirements of Article 19 of the Federal Law "On Advertising."
The Supreme Court overturned the district court’s ruling and reinstated the decisions of the lower courts. It is essential to distinguish between two separate legal regimes:
🔹Advertising legislation: governs the installation and operation of advertising structures, including the procurement of permits where required by law.
🔹Municipal urban improvement regulations: establish independent requirements regarding the appearance of buildings and the placement of signs or informational structures on facades and roofs.
In this case, the company had violated these local requirements. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation clarified that, regardless of whether a site is classified as an advertisement or an informational sign, its placement must comply with the full scope of applicable requirements.
Practical Takeaway: The legality of installing a structure should be verified across several criteria:
✅possession of a permit (if the site is classified as an advertising structure);
✅compliance with the municipal entity’s urban improvement regulations;
✅existence of a resolution from a general meeting of property owners, if the structure is installed on the roof of an apartment building (Clause 3, Part 2, Article 44 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation).
Clause 3: The legality of an appellate court ruling—issued following proceedings conducted under standard litigation rules—must be reviewed by the cassation court without applying the special provisions of Article 288.2 of the Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation (which govern cassation appeals for cases originally heard under simplified (summary) procedures).
This position stems from a dispute in which the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation addressed how a change in procedural form affects subsequent judicial review.
Case Summary:
🔹Court of first instance: Simplified procedure.
🔹Appellate court: Standard litigation (plenary) procedure.
🔹Cassation court: Simplified procedure.
The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation deemed this approach erroneous, clarifying that the initial procedural form of a case does not automatically dictate the procedure for all subsequent stages.
Furthermore, the applicable procedure determines the composition of the court, which relates to a fundamental procedural guarantee: the right to have one’s case heard by a lawfully constituted court. Adjudication by an improperly constituted court serves as an absolute ground for overturning a judicial decision.
Practical Takeaway: When preparing a cassation appeal against an appellate court ruling, one must first determine the procedure under which the case was heard on appeal, as this dictates both the review process in the cassation court and the required composition of the court. A violation of the rules regarding the composition of the court may be cited as an absolute ground for setting aside a judicial act (Part 4 of Article 288 of the Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation).
You can find the first post here.
In this post, we will discuss the Supreme Court’s positions regarding advertising legislation and procedural matters.
Clause 3: The installation of an advertising structure on a building’s roof, in the absence of evidence that the established public regulatory procedures for such installation were followed, constitutes grounds for the mandatory dismantling of the structure, regardless of its functional purpose.
This legal position emerged from a dispute reviewed by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, which addressed the necessity of complying not only with advertising legislation but also with broader public regulatory requirements.
A municipal authority issued an order to a company to dismantle an advertising structure placed on its roof, citing the lack of a required installation permit.
The courts of first instance and the appellate court upheld the order as lawful. However, the district cassation court took a different view, arguing that the structure in question was an informational sign rather than an advertisement; therefore, its placement did not fall under the requirements of Article 19 of the Federal Law "On Advertising."
The Supreme Court overturned the district court’s ruling and reinstated the decisions of the lower courts. It is essential to distinguish between two separate legal regimes:
🔹Advertising legislation: governs the installation and operation of advertising structures, including the procurement of permits where required by law.
🔹Municipal urban improvement regulations: establish independent requirements regarding the appearance of buildings and the placement of signs or informational structures on facades and roofs.
In this case, the company had violated these local requirements. The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation clarified that, regardless of whether a site is classified as an advertisement or an informational sign, its placement must comply with the full scope of applicable requirements.
Practical Takeaway: The legality of installing a structure should be verified across several criteria:
✅possession of a permit (if the site is classified as an advertising structure);
✅compliance with the municipal entity’s urban improvement regulations;
✅existence of a resolution from a general meeting of property owners, if the structure is installed on the roof of an apartment building (Clause 3, Part 2, Article 44 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation).
Clause 3: The legality of an appellate court ruling—issued following proceedings conducted under standard litigation rules—must be reviewed by the cassation court without applying the special provisions of Article 288.2 of the Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation (which govern cassation appeals for cases originally heard under simplified (summary) procedures).
This position stems from a dispute in which the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation addressed how a change in procedural form affects subsequent judicial review.
Case Summary:
🔹Court of first instance: Simplified procedure.
🔹Appellate court: Standard litigation (plenary) procedure.
🔹Cassation court: Simplified procedure.
The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation deemed this approach erroneous, clarifying that the initial procedural form of a case does not automatically dictate the procedure for all subsequent stages.
Furthermore, the applicable procedure determines the composition of the court, which relates to a fundamental procedural guarantee: the right to have one’s case heard by a lawfully constituted court. Adjudication by an improperly constituted court serves as an absolute ground for overturning a judicial decision.
Practical Takeaway: When preparing a cassation appeal against an appellate court ruling, one must first determine the procedure under which the case was heard on appeal, as this dictates both the review process in the cassation court and the required composition of the court. A violation of the rules regarding the composition of the court may be cited as an absolute ground for setting aside a judicial act (Part 4 of Article 288 of the Arbitration Procedural Code of the Russian Federation).